VA Cancer Patients Less Likely to Receive Excessive Care at End of Life

by Brenda Mooney

February 9, 2018

Do Financial Incentives Lead to More Medicare Interventions?

By Brenda L. Mooney

PALO ALTO, CA—VA patients dying of cancer are far less likely to receive excessive and unnecessary end-of-life interventions than those treated by Medicare.

In a report published in the journal Health Affairs, study authors warned that pushing for VA to become more of a purchaser than provider of medical services could mean lower quality care in situations such as this.1

Julian Scadden, a 67-year-old Vietnam-Era veterans, comforts the dying at the Denver VA’s Community Living Center. VA photo

“The findings are not just important for veterans and VA policy, but for anybody who needs medical care at the end of life, which is a majority of us,” said Risha Gidwani-Marszowski, DrPH, a health economist at the VA Health Economics Resource Center at the Palo Alto VAMC and a consulting assistant professor of medicine at Stanford University. “We as a society need to ensure we are setting up the organization of healthcare and its financial incentives to ensure that the services patients receive are the ones that are in their best interests at the end of life.”

Study authors also sounded a warning about changes in VA promoted by some congressional and VA leaders. “Fee-for-service Medicare provides an example of how purchased care differs from the VA’s directly provided care,” they noted. “Using established indicators of overly intensive end-of-life care, we compared the quality of care provided through the two systems to veterans dying of cancer in fiscal years 2010–14. The Medicare-reliant veterans were significantly more likely to receive high-intensity care, in the form of chemotherapy, hospital stays, admission to the intensive care unit, more days spent in the hospital and death in the hospital.”

On the other hand, researchers pointed out, the VA patients were more likely to have multiple emergency department visits.

Higher Intensity Care

Still, they emphasized, “Higher-intensity end-of-life care may be driven by financial incentives present in fee-for-service Medicare but not in the VA’s integrated system. To avoid putting VA-reliant veterans at risk of receiving lower-quality care, VA care-purchasing programs should develop coordination and quality monitoring programs to guard against overly intensive end-of-life care.”

The proposed Veterans Empowerment Act would change the VA so that it mostly funds medical services, along the lines of Medicare, rather than providing all the care itself. Ultimately, Gidwani-Marszowski cautioned, those types of changes could expose veterans to any effects a Medicare-like funding approach has on end-of-life care.

To determine whether the way care is organized affects the level of end-of-life services for veterans dying of cancer, researchers focused on 87,251 veterans older than 66 who had solid tumors and died between October 2009 and September 2014.

The definition of care quality was derived from guidelines issued by the American Society of Clinical Oncology and the National Quality Forum. The study team also took into account research on what services patients consider undesirable or burdensome at the end of life.

Specifically, the study looked at whether patients:

  • received chemotherapy;
  • had two or more emergency department visits;
  • were admitted to the hospital and how many days they spent there; or
  • died in the hospital and/or were admitted to intensive care.

For purposes of the study, the higher the numbers of veterans receiving these services, the lower the quality of care.

Veterans with cancer who used VA healthcare were then compared with veterans with cancer who received their care through Medicare. Background information in the study noted that more than 90% percent of older veterans are enrolled in Medicare, as well as the VA, so the population that is eligible for both programs. That makes the situation ideal for evaluating differences in care due to health care system factors, Gidwani-Marszowski pointed out.

Results indicated that Medicare patients were more likely to receive excessive intensive care at the end of life including chemotherapy, hospitalization, admission to the intensive care unit, longer stays in the hospital and death in the hospital, than those who received care through the VA.

Why did that occur? Gidwani-Marszowski suggested that the different financial incentives of the two systems explain the variation.

For example, she said, VA physicians are salaried, while Medicare-funded physicians bill according to the services provided (i.e., service). Additional services provided through Medicare generate funds for physicians and health care organizations.

Gidwani-Marszowski also offered an explanation as to why VA patients were more likely than Medicare patients to have two or more emergency department visits. She said extended hours or access to appointments are not available at all VA facilities, which might push veterans to the ED when they experience a medical problem. In addition, she said, Medicare patients with the same issue are more likely to already be in the hospital and receiving the care VA patients are seeking at an ED.

“The VA has long been a leader in providing patient-centered care at the end of life,” noted senior author Steven Asch, MD, professor of medicine at Stanford. Asch said. “Our study showed that veterans can expect appropriately lower-intensity care as they face late-stage cancer at VA facilities. If they choose instead to use their Medicare benefits outside the VA, they are at greater risk of getting chemotherapy, hospitalization and other services that will likely not help them in their last days.”

  1. Gidwani-Marszowski R, Needleman J, Mor V, Faricy-Anderson K, Boothroyd DB, Hsin G, Wagner TH, Lorenz KA, Patel MI, Joyce VR, Murrell SS, Ramchandran K, Asch Quality Of End-Of-Life Care Is Higher In The VA Compared To Care Paid For By Traditional Medicare. Health Aff (Millwood). 2018 Jan;37(1):95-103. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2017.0883. PubMed PMID: 29309227.

Comments are closed here.


Related Articles

Advocates Square Off Against VA on Women’s Veterans Task Force’s Role

WASHINGTON—It’s been nearly six months since the House VA Committee launched its bipartisan Women Veterans Task Force, and the result is a legislative docket filled with bills geared toward ensuring VA has the resources it... View Article

VBA Improves Oversight of Outside Contractors But Some Gaps Remain

WASHINGTON—Nearly a year after a Government Accountability Office report revealed that the Veterans’ Benefit Administration had been unable to track the quality, accuracy, and timeliness of the outside contractors hired to conduct compensation and pension... View Article


U.S. Medicine Recommends


More From department of veterans affairs

Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)

Seeing Combat Can Make Aging More Difficult for Veterans

PORTLAND, OR—Being exposed to combat makes a significant difference in how military veterans fare during aging, according to a new study, which also found that the experience increases the risk for depression and anxiety later... View Article

Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)

Top VISN 7 Officials Removed After Cancer Patient Attacked by Insects

Elderly AF Veteran Had More Than 100 Ant Bites Before Death ATLANTA—Nine VA employees, including the VISN 7 director and chief medical officer, have been reassigned following reports that an elderly patient at the Atlanta... View Article

Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)

Women, Chronically Ill Veterans Value Veterans Choice Access Most

HINES, IL—Women and veterans with multiple comorbidities used and valued the Veterans Choice Program (VCP) more than other veterans, according to recent research by the VA.1 To help these veterans and others, the VA has... View Article

Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)

VA Facing Critical Healthcare Staffing Shortages in Near Future

Replacing Retirees Hampered by Lower Salaries WASHINGTON—Oversight agencies are sounding the alarm that VA is plagued with large staffing shortages in critical areas, including physicians, registered nurses, physician assistants, psychologists and physical therapists, as well... View Article

Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)

Processes Similar in Schizophrenia, Psychotic Biopolar Disorder

NASHVILLE, TN—Processes leading to impairment in schizophrenia and psychotic bipolar disorder might be more similar than previously assumed, according to a new study. The report in Schizophrenia Research pointed out that neuropsychological impairment is common... View Article

Subscribe to U.S. Medicine Print Magazine

U.S. Medicine is mailed free each month to physicians, pharmacists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants and administrators working for Veterans Affairs, Department of Defense and U.S. Public Health Service.

Subscribe Now

Receive Our Email Newsletter

Stay informed about federal medical news, clinical updates and reports on government topics for the federal healthcare professional.

Sign Up