2011 Issues   /   November 2011

Do HHS Proposed Changes to Common Rule Go Far Enough, Critics Ask

By US Medicine

BETHESDA, MD — This summer, HHS announced a proposal to improve the rules governing the protection of human research subjects — a system usually referred to as the Common Rule, which has been in place since 1991. While the proposed changes are wide-ranging, some critics question whether the revisions go far enough or do anything to better protect human subjects.   

In July, a notice of proposed rulemaking (ANPRM) was published

in the Federal Register, laying out proposed changes and soliciting comments from the research community. Those proposals, entitled “Human Subjects Research Protections: Enhancing Protections for Research Subjects and Reducing Burden, Delay, and Ambiguity for Investigators,” included revisions to risk-based protection rules.

HHS is proposing to no longer keep Institutional Review Board (IRB) reviews going once a study has reached the data-examination phase. Also, while there now are categories of studies, such as surveys that are exempt from a review, HHS is proposing those studies be held to a data-protection standard and officially tracked by the agency.

The ANPRM also targets informed consent forms, which have been heavily criticized as being too technical, too lengthy and with no highlighting of the important points that a research subject should know. HHS is proposing to prescribe appropriate content as well as dictate appropriate length, because some consent forms can be as long as 50 pages.

HHS also proposes an overhaul of how multisite studies are reviewed. Currently, a domestic multisite study could be reviewed by dozens or hundreds of IRBs, with no clear evidence that more IRB reviews bring added protection. HHS proposes to have a single IRB of record for all domestic, multisite studies.

The agency also proposes that all federally funded human research fall under the Common Rule. Six categories of research currently are exempt: research in education settings involving educational practices; research involving educational tests if the subjects are elected officials and if federal status requires confidentiality; research involving the collection of existing data; research designed to study public benefit or service programs; and taste and food quality evaluation and consumer acceptance studies.

All such studies that receive federal funding would be held to Common Rule regulations if the proposal becomes law.

The proposal also tackles “regulatory harmonization.” After the Common Rule was adopted in 1991, each federal agency was allowed to create its own set of additional guidance regarding human subject protection. Consequently, each federal agency has differing guidelines, which sometimes conflict with each other. The ANPRM would require consistency of regulations across the federal government.


Related Articles

Engineer Seeks to Make VAMCs More Energy Efficient Without Interrupting Their Mission

WASHINGTON—Anyone who’s ever worked in a hospital knows how much energy a facility of that size consumes. From the electricity to keep the lights on and the technology running to the water used to keep everything sterile, medical facilities can be far from energy efficient.

GAO: Applications for VHA Healthcare Benefits Frequently Mishandled

VHA does not have the right protocols in place to ensure applications for enrollment are processed in a timely manner or that enrollment determinations are accurate, according to a new report.


U.S. Medicine Recommends


More From hhs and usphs

Department of Defense (DoD)

Telemedicine Allows Army, Indian Health Service to Expand Range of Diabetes Care

To reach the growing number of individuals in their care who have diabetes, both the Army and the Indian Health Service have aggressively adopted telemedicine

Pharmacists Play Big Role in More-Restrictive IHS Opioid Prescribing Rules

Vascular Events Lead to Stroke About a Fourth of the Time. INDIANAPOLIS — While many healthcare systems measure the quality of their stroke care, looking at performance early in the vascular disease process can help... View Article

Study Determines Patients Most Vulnerable to E. Coli H30

Vascular Events Lead to Stroke About a Fourth of the Time. INDIANAPOLIS — While many healthcare systems measure the quality of their stroke care, looking at performance early in the vascular disease process can help... View Article

HHS and USPHS

Stroke Kills Young American Indian/Alaska Natives at Twice Rate of Whites

Vascular Events Lead to Stroke About a Fourth of the Time. INDIANAPOLIS — While many healthcare systems measure the quality of their stroke care, looking at performance early in the vascular disease process can help... View Article

Department of Defense (DoD)

Uniformed Pharmacists Take Half of Next Generation Pharmacist Awards

Vascular Events Lead to Stroke About a Fourth of the Time. INDIANAPOLIS — While many healthcare systems measure the quality of their stroke care, looking at performance early in the vascular disease process can help... View Article

Facebook Comment

Subscribe to U.S. Medicine Print Magazine

U.S. Medicine is mailed free each month to physicians, pharmacists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants and administrators working for Veterans Affairs, Department of Defense and U.S. Public Health Service.

Subscribe Now

Receive Our Email Newsletter

Stay informed about federal medical news, clinical updates and reports on government topics for the federal healthcare professional.

Sign Up