Advertisement
Departments | Specialty Focus | Non-Clinical Topics | News | Special Issues | e-Newsletter | Education | Archive | Site Search

VA Seeks to Increase Flu Vaccine Rates for Healthcare Staff after Last Years Drop Cont.

Increasing healthcare workers’ vaccination rates significantly above the 77% average achieved in 2009 will take a coordinated effort. “Two actions will make a significant difference in reaching the 85% goal this flu season,” Martinello said. “First, leadership at every facility must recognize that vaccinating healthcare workers is a high priority for the VA and communicate that throughout the organization, so the message rises above the competition.” Facility leaders can demonstrate the importance of vaccination by ensuring that directors, service chiefs, chief residents and other managers get their vaccines and personally encourage their staffs to follow their example.

“Second, facility leadership must devote sufficient resources to make the vaccine easily accessible. That means making as many people available as possible to conduct vaccinations of healthcare workers, ensuring sufficient vaccine is on hand, providing space for vaccinations, and allocating mobile carts to take vaccines to people,” he added. Offering FluMist and intradermal vaccine, when appropriate, may also increase vaccination rates.

Nurses on transitional duty and nursing students can supplement regular employees to extend occupational health clinic hours, increase locations where vaccinations are available, and staff mobile vaccine carts.

Documentation Critical

To avoid underreporting of vaccination rates, the VA’s “Infection: Don’t Pass It On” team strongly encourages facilities to train all employees responsible for documentation on the proper procedures for entering data in the OHRS, as outlined in the VA Influenza Manual 2011-2012. Facilities also might consider distributing postcards to enable identification of workers who received their vaccinations elsewhere. Tracking who has been vaccinated in OHRS allows influenza vaccine campaign coordinators to send reminders to those who still need vaccination. Surveying stragglers also helps campaign planners develop effective materials to allay concerns or address misconceptions healthcare personnel might have about the flu vaccine.

While it might seem late in the season to focus on vaccination rates, Nichol pointed out that 60% of flu seasons do not peak until February. Influenza remains prevalent in many communities through March in most years, and CDC data shows that about 15% of flu seasons have their peak activity in March or later. Most recently, the first wave of the 2009 H1N1 pandemic occurred from mid-April to early May.

In addition to the health concerns, workdays lost by HCWs who contract influenza can be costly. The authors of the Disaster Medicine study estimate that economic burden of sick days taken by VA healthcare workers who contracted influenza during the second wave of the 2009 pandemic exceeded $20 million during a six-week period.

CDC recommends that all healthcare workers receive annual influenza vaccination to prevent transmission and avoid disruption of services. The U.S. Public Health Service’s Healthy People 20220 sets a minimum coverage rate of 90% among healthcare workers. Despite these recommendations, their national vaccination rates remain below 65%.

Influenza Vaccination Compared with National Vaccination Rates

AGE?

2007/2008

2008/2009

2009/2010

2010/2011

VHA 65+

84%

83%

82%

79%

US 65+

66%

66%

70%

69%

VHA 40-64

69%

69%

71%

65%

US 50-64

38%

40%

45%

46%

VHA HCW

65%

64%

77%

54% *

US HCW

49%

NA

62%

64%

  • Not all facilities documented seasonal influenza vaccinations in OHRS.

Chart from 2011-2012 VA Influenza Manual

Sutdy in Disaster Medicine

Back to February Articles


Comments (4)

Thomas, Robert, MD, MPH&TM
Said this on 3-8-2012 At 05:47 pm
Although many well-meaning people might respond in an enthusiastic sociopolitically correct manner, a scientific approach is necessary when dealing wiith patients and care-givers. Injectable immunizations are not completely benign. An appropriate risk-benefit appraisal has to be made in relation to herd immunity for the intended population before generalizations start to determine health policy.
Said this on 3-6-2012 At 01:42 pm
Flu Immunization should be mandatory for VA employees and volunteers. Those who care for veterans do not have the right to put them in danger. The benefits of immunization far outweigh the risks. The VA cares for many vulnerable people, some of whom are too ill to be vaccinated, some for whom the vaccine may not be effective. The VA has a duty to protect them from the preventable exposure to potentially dangerous or fatal illness. The flu can kill healthy people and the vulnerable, and the VA has a duty to protect them; patients, co-workers, and volunteers. There is no perfect or risk free course of action, but there is no better choice for the VA than mandatory immunizations.
Marzolf,James MD MPH
Said this on 3-6-2012 At 12:21 pm
I am puzzled by the 85-90% goal and have looked for the empirical basis for it but have yet to find it.

Recent meta-analyses indicates that there is no evidence that vaccinating HCWs prevents influenza in elderly residents in LTCFs, no guidance regarding the safety, efficacy or effectiveness of influenza vaccines for people aged 65 years or older, and that vaccine use did not affect the number of people hospitalized or working days lost but caused one case of Guillian‐Barré syndrome for every one million vaccinations.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmedhealth/PMH001094...
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20166073
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20166072

In summary, the Cochrane analyses found “most studies flawed. Studies were not randomized, had difficulty in analyzing trial conditions, had no controls, and there was confusion between influenza and influenza-like infections, which can result in an over-estimation of the true impact of the illness and flu deaths. In addition, not enough studies were done on the safety of vaccines.”

http://jama.ama-assn.org/content/296/16/1990.short

Here’s a good example of the shabby research the meta-analysis is talking about. It was funded by CDC and conducted by Kaiser Permanente. It was a nonrandomized analysis of the records of babies 6 to 23 months old who were given flu shots plus other vaccines between 1991 and 2003. No unvaccinated controls were used. “The study used only the cases of those who had seen the doctor within 14 days of receiving the flu vaccination. These criteria eliminated dozens of cases of adverse effects, including convulsions and brain injury. Some of the cases of convulsions and Guillain-Barre syndrome were attributed to other vaccines or coincidence. Of the 19 investigators, nine had financial ties to vaccine manufacturers.” Whew!!!

Add to that the October 2011 study published in Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology which indicated that there was no demonstrable increase in efficacy above 75% employee vaccination levels in terms of preventing laboratory confirmed influenza cases and I’d have to say it’s not a very compelling argument for mandatory vaccination of employees if we are already hitting 75%. However, mandating it is a sure litigation multiplier.
Florence Dyer,NP
Said this on 3-5-2012 At 05:07 pm
Although I encourage everyone to get all their immunizations, I do not support the mandatory Flu vaccinatino for health care workers because:
-The Fly vaccine is only 60 % effective. Those that are immunized against the Flu can still have and spread the Flu 40% of the time and they may have a false sense of security and not follow regular prevention habits such has: cover your cough, wash your hands, stay home when sick.
-The Flu vaccines does have potential serious health risk.
-Once it is a go for one vaccine, the door is opened for mandatory "anything";What will be the next mandatory substance to be imposed? This is simply too much control on people lives and body.
-If the vaccine is 95 to 100% effective, health workers will probably take it spontaneously.
- Health workers are not the only factor in patients getting exposed to Flu: their visitors, their family also can give them the Flu.
Post a Comment (showhide)
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
(not publicly displayed)
Reply Notification:
Approval Notification:
Website:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image:
* Message:

Advertisement