<--GAT-->
Non-Clinical Topics

VA Reverses Stance, Won’t Challenge ‘Blue Water’ Veteran Court Ruling

by Stephen Spotswood

May 14, 2019

WASHINGTON—In an about-face, the VA will recommend that the federal government not challenge a recent court decision ruling that the department cannot deny benefits to Vietnam-era Blue Water Navy veterans claiming Agent Orange exposure.

The news came from VA Secretary Robert Wilkie, who told legislators at a hearing last month. This reverses a stance that Wilkie and VA took last fall when Congress attempted to pass legislation granting Blue Water veterans automatic presumption of exposure to the toxic defoliant. This could signal the end to a roller-coaster ride of legislation, policy changes and court cases that have kept Blue Water veterans in a kind of legal limbo for decades.

In 1991, Congress passed the Agent Orange Act, which granted any veteran who had served in the Republic of Vietnam during the Vietnam War a presumptive service connection for Agent Orange exposure. The defoliant had been linked to illnesses such as heart disease, Parkinson’s, Type 2 diabetes and a laundry list of cancers. A presumptive connection could impact those veterans’ VA benefits and make it easier to receive care.

In 1997, VA’s general counsel held that “in The Republic of Vietnam” did not extend to ships serving off the coast. In 2002, this opinion was codified in VA’s internal policy, limiting the presumptive service connection to those servicemembers who served on land or in the inland waterways of Vietnam. In 2006, the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims issued a decision in Haas v. Peake stating that the presumption should extend to Blue Water veterans. In 2008, the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit overturned that decision.

Attempts to change VA policy in the legislative arena were equally frustrating for Blue Water veterans.

In May 2018, the House passed the Blue Water Navy Vietnam Veterans Act of 2017 which would have reinstated benefits for Blue Water veterans. While that bill passed with full bipartisan support and 329 co-sponsors in the House, it stalled in the Senate. A handful of senators cited the bill’s budget impact and a lack of definitive evidence proving veterans off the coast of Vietnam had been exposed to Agent Orange. Their hesitancy kept the bill from reaching a vote on the Senate floor before the 115th Congress adjourned at the end of 2018.

But while legislators were drafting, revising and ultimately coming to an impasse on the bill, another case was making its way through the courts—Procopio v. Wilkie.

A Blue Water Navy veteran, Alfred Procopio Jr. served on the USS Intrepid in July 1966 when it was stationed off the coast of Vietnam. In 2009, VA twice denied service entitlement for his prostate cancer and Type 2 diabetes. A series of appeals to the Board of Veterans Appeals were denied, and the Court of Veterans Appeals upheld VA’s decision in 2016.

Procopio’s lawyers appealed his case to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, and in January of this year the court voted 9-2 to overturn its decision in Haas v. Peake, stating that Congress’ intent in using the phrase “in The Republic of Vietnam” included the waters offshore.

This decision effectively reincludes Blue Water Navy veterans in the umbrella of presumptive service connection for Agent Orange exposure. However, it’s still possible for the federal government to appeal the court’s decision.

Appearing before the Senate VA committee last month, Wilkie said he would be recommending that no appeal be filed. While he cautioned legislators that he did not have the final say in whether the government challenged the ruling, his recommendation will weigh heavily in the final decision.

During the hearing, Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-NY) suggested that VA turn its attention to the toxic conditions found on modern battlefields, including those surrounding burn pits—a common way of disposing of waste at military sites in Iraq and Afghanistan.

“I agree with you,” Wilkie said. “We don’t want to go through what we went through with Agent Orange.”



Related Articles

Technology Experts Question MISSION Act Electronic Systems

WASHINGTON—VA is working under a tight deadline to implement the community care provisions of the MISSION Act, the new law that goes into effect this summer and revises and codifies access standards for veterans receiving... View Article

VA Study Raises Questions About Value of Readmission Metrics

SAN FRANCISCO—While the VA performs well overall on key 30-day readmission rates, a study by researchers at the San Francisco VAMC questioned the utility of the measures for most of the health system’s hospitals. The... View Article


U.S. Medicine Recommends


More From legislation

Legislation

Executive Order Creates Task Force to Combat Veteran Suicide

WASHINGTON—High turnover among leadership, gaps in accountability, and long-standing problems in cybersecurity represent significant challenges for VA in its ongoing efforts to improve its IT infrastructure, oversight officials told legislators last month. These challenges will... View Article

Legislation

Legislators Express Outrage Over Military Sexual Trauma Issues Subhead: Senator Describes Her Experience as Air Force Rape Victim

WASHINGTON—High turnover among leadership, gaps in accountability, and long-standing problems in cybersecurity represent significant challenges for VA in its ongoing efforts to improve its IT infrastructure, oversight officials told legislators last month. These challenges will... View Article

Legislation

Senate Votes Overwhelmingly to Make Robert L. Wilkie the New VA Secretary

Robert L. Wilkie took office as the 10th VA Secretary after the U.S. Senate voted 86-9 to confirm him.

Legislation

VA secretary nominee promises opposition to healthcare privatization

VA Secretary nominee Robert L. Wilkie promised lawmakers he would not privatize VA healthcare if he is confirmed.

Legislation

House subcommittee pushes for burn pit exposure answers

The VA and its partners are pursuing research, including six major studies, to better understand the potential health effects of burn pit exposures.

Subscribe to U.S. Medicine Print Magazine

U.S. Medicine is mailed free each month to physicians, pharmacists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants and administrators working for Veterans Affairs, Department of Defense and U.S. Public Health Service.

Subscribe Now

Receive Our Email Newsletter

Stay informed about federal medical news, clinical updates and reports on government topics for the federal healthcare professional.

Sign Up