High Percentage of Soldiers with Mental Illness Undiagnosed, Not Being Treated

by U.S. Medicine

January 3, 2016

By Annette M. Boyle

Spc. Jack Buckwalter, a mental health specialist with HHC, 1st ACB, 1st Cav. Div., provided triage to a soldier during a behavioral health assessment at Troop Medical Clinic 12 at Hood Army Airfield, TX. Photo by Sgt. Christopher Calvert

Spc. Jack Buckwalter, a mental health specialist with HHC, 1st ACB, 1st Cav. Div., provided triage to a soldier during a behavioral health assessment at Troop Medical Clinic 12 at Hood Army Airfield, TX. Photo by Sgt. Christopher Calvert

BETHESDA, MD — In the wake of record-high suicide rates, the Army instituted a number of programs to identify and treat mental illness among soldiers.

New research indicates that DoD might be on the right track. Recent findings suggested that almost 80% of soldiers with mental disorders are not receiving any treatment whatsoever.

Rates of current treatment were lowest among soldiers with major depressive disorder at 26.6% and those with externalizing disorders, at an average of 20.6%. In contrast, at least 40% of soldiers with bipolar disorder and panic disorder were receiving treatment.

Overall, only 21.3% of soldiers with any mental illness were receiving any current treatment, according to a study published in the October issue of Military Medicine.1

The new data comes from a de-identified survey component of the Army Study to Assess Risk and Resilience in Service members (Army STARRS), a large, multicomponent epidemiological-neurobiological study of risk and resilience factors for suicide. The self-administered questionnaire went to a representative sample of nondeployed regular Army soldiers in the last three quarters of 2011. The survey had a 65% completion rate.

Survey respondents completed the Composite International Diagnostic Interview screening scales and a modified version of the post-traumatic stress disorder checklist to determine current mental disorders. They were also asked how many months in the past year each identified disorder had caused problems for them and how seriously they interfered with their functioning at home, work, social life and personal relationships.

Respondents were considered to be in current treatment if they had received medication, psychological counseling or spiritual counseling in the past 12 months and had responded positively to a follow-up question that asked whether they were still in treatment. Those in counseling were asked to specify whether they received care from a mental health professional, general medical professional, spiritual adviser or self-help group.

Researchers led by U.S. Public Health Service Capt. Lisa Colpe, PhD, MPH, chief of the Office of Clinical and Population Epidemiology Research in the Division of Services and Intervention Research at the National Institute of Mental Health, found that seven characteristics predicted whether someone would be in treatment.

The factors included being or having been married, not being non-Hispanic black, history of deployment, diagnoses of bipolar disorder or panic disorder, having any disorder for an extended period of time and having PTSD. The more factors a soldier had, the higher the likelihood of current treatment, with PTSD given twice the weight of other variables.

Soldiers who had six or seven factors comprised 15% of the total sample, but 25% of those reported that they were receiving care. Of them, 71.5% were in treatment, whereas only 32.2% of those with four or five factors were receiving therapy and 11.4% of those with two or three of the variables. Less than 5% of those with only one factor were currently receiving treatment.

“We attempted to identify a set of characteristics that could be used to help target groups who aren’t getting services,” said Colpe, but the study showed that the few soldiers had a high number of predictors.

[Click image to Enlarge]  Proportions of Cases Treated in Each Treatment Sector Among Soldiers With a 30-Day DSM-IV Mental Disorder Who Are Currently in Treatment in the Army STARRS Q2–4 2011 AAS (n = 324)  *Significant association between number of disorders and proportional treatment in the sector based on a 0.05-level 2-sided test. a AAS respondents within each row who are currently receiving any mental health treatment. (b) Mental health specialty defined as treatment by a psychiatrist, psychologist, drug or alcohol counselor, mental health counselor or social worker, or marriage and family counselor. psychologist, drug or alcohol counselor, mental health counselor or social worker, or marriage and family counselor. (c) General medical defined as treatment either by a military medic or by a general medical doctor, nurse, or physician’s assistant. (d) Human services defined as counseling by a military chaplain or by a civilian minister, priest, rabbi, or other spiritual advisor. (e) Self-help defined as participating in a self-help or support group (without a mental health professional running the group) either at a military facility or associated with the military, or in a civilian self-help or support group. (f) Weighted “row” percentages denoting the proportion of AAS respondents within each row who are currently receiving each type of mental health treatment.

[Click image to Enlarge]
Proportions of Cases Treated in Each Treatment Sector Among Soldiers With a 30-Day DSM-IV Mental Disorder Who Are Currently in Treatment in the Army STARRS Q2–4 2011 AAS (n = 324)
*Significant association between number of disorders and proportional treatment in the sector based on a 0.05-level 2-sided test. a AAS respondents within each row who are currently receiving any mental health treatment. (b) Mental health specialty defined as treatment by a psychiatrist, psychologist, drug or alcohol counselor, mental health counselor or social worker, or marriage and family counselor. psychologist, drug or alcohol counselor, mental health counselor or social worker, or marriage and family counselor. (c) General medical defined as treatment either by a military medic or by a general medical doctor, nurse, or physician’s assistant. (d) Human services defined as counseling by a military chaplain or by a civilian minister, priest, rabbi, or other spiritual advisor. (e) Self-help defined as participating in a self-help or support group (without a mental health professional running the group) either at a military facility or associated with the military, or in a civilian self-help or support group. (f) Weighted “row” percentages denoting the proportion of AAS respondents within each row who are currently receiving each type of mental health treatment.

As she and her colleagues noted in the study, “untreated soldiers are not concentrated in a particular segment of the population that might be targeted for special outreach efforts,” which will make reaching them more challenging.

Overall, “treatment rates are pretty low. It’s only when you look at disorders that are severely impairing or long in duration that treatment rates get above 50%, and even then, only for certain disorders,” Colpe told U.S. Medicine.

Of those soldiers who considered their mental disorder “severely impairing,” 32% were receiving treatment, twice the rate of those who did not think it severely affected their ability to function effectively. Severe impairment doubled the treatment rate, regardless of type of disorder (internalizing or externalizing), although less than 40% of those with any externalizing disorder were currently in treatment.

Among those with internalizing disorders who considered the condition severely impairing, 59% with panic disorder were in treatment, as were 52% of those with PTSD. Nearly 47% of soldiers with severely impairing bipolar disorder said they were currently receiving treatment, as did 43.8% of those with generalized anxiety disorder. Only 29% of those with severe impairment from major depression said they were in treatment.

“The comparatively high treatment rates associated with PD, BPD, PTSD and GAD among the internalizing disorders might reflect higher levels of psychological distress associated with those disorders,” the authors said. Soldiers might also see symptoms of these disorders as more “understandable consequences of military life and legitimate reasons for seeking treatment,” they noted.

While direct comparison of the Army data with civilian data is challenging, civilians who rate their conditions as severe are also twice as likely to be in treatment than those who say it is mild, according to Colpe.

The rate of treatment within the Army cohort might be so low for reasons also seen in the general population: “The demographics of the soldier population, with 90% under the age of 40 and 42% under the age of 25, and 85% male, are characteristics associated with lower treatment rates in the civilian population, too,” she pointed out.

1 Colpe LJ, Naifeh JA, Aliaga PA, Sampson NA, Heering SG, Stein MB, et al. Mental Health Treatment Among Soldiers with Current Mental Disorders in the Army Study to Assess Risk and Resilience in Service Members (Army STARRS). Military Medicine. 2015. 180, 10:1041-1051.


2 Comments

  • Cole Cameron says:

    We use writing prompts like “What was your earliest traumatic experience?”, as a precursor to military trauma in addressing PTSD and Moral Injury in our program, Veteran Healing Veterans from the Inside Out at San Quentin Prison.

    Most have been in 20+ and have found our peer to peer program offers the safest and trusting group environment they have ever had. The parolee’s are doing well.

    A. Cole Cameron, 1st Lt, Viet Era Vet,
    Outside Group Facilitator
    San Quentin’s Veterans Healing Veterans, from the Inside Out

  • Cole Cameron says:

    We use writing prompts like “What was your earliest traumatic experience?”, as a precursor to military trauma in addressing PTSD and Moral Injury in our program, Veteran Healing Veterans from the Inside Out at San Quentin Prison.

    Most have been in 20+ and have found our peer to peer program offers the safest and trusting group environment they have ever had. The parolee’s are doing well.

    A. Cole Cameron, 1st Lt, Viet Era Vet,
    Outside Group Facilitator
    San Quentin’s Veterans Healing Veterans, from the Inside Out


Related Articles

Political Issues Related to VA’s Limited Approval of Esketamine for Depression

WASHINGTON—A VA panel this summer opted not to add the new depression medication esketamine, Spravato, to the department’s formulary in the usual way. This came despite strong support from President Donald Trump and an effort... View Article

Debate Continues on Esketamine Efficacy and Safety for Depression Treatment

VA Panel Puts Limits on Use of Drug PHILADELPHIA—Is esketamine a revolutionary treatment for depression or just another moderately effective adjunctive medication with some potentially serious risks? The VA’s Medical Advisory Panel leaned toward the... View Article


U.S. Medicine Recommends


More From department of defense dod

Department of Defense (DoD)

DoD acknowledges its medical adverse event reporting is ‘unreliable’

The process for tracking the DoD’s most serious adverse medical events is “fragmented, impeding the Defense Health Agency’s (DHA) ability to ensure that it has received complete information,” according to a new review.

Department of Defense (DoD)

Automation Speeds Results and Increases Accuracy for Point-of-Care Testing at Walter Reed NMMC

With a long history of point of care testing at both of its predecessor organizations, the Walter Reed National Military Medical Center (WRNMMC) laboratory services staff were keenly aware of the advantages of using portable testing devices to obtain rapid patient assessments.

Department of Defense (DoD)

High Rate of Pectoralis Tears Among Deployed Servicemembers Lifting Weights

Lifting weights is one way servicemembers keep in peak physical condition during deployment.

Department of Defense (DoD)

DoD Study Finds That Type 2 Diabetes Increases Breast Cancer Mortality

Having Type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM-2) increases mortality risk in breast cancer patients, regardless of whether diabetes was diagnosed before or after breast cancer, according to a recent study.

Department of Defense (DoD)

Now Hear This: Otolaryngologist Leads Effort to Prevent Auditory Issues

Among those who are exposed to combat, it’s the weapons fire that does it. In the Navy, it’s the noise levels in engine rooms and on the decks of carriers.

Subscribe to U.S. Medicine Print Magazine

U.S. Medicine is mailed free each month to physicians, pharmacists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants and administrators working for Veterans Affairs, Department of Defense and U.S. Public Health Service.

Subscribe Now

Receive Our Email Newsletter

Stay informed about federal medical news, clinical updates and reports on government topics for the federal healthcare professional.

Sign Up