It is curious that physical courage should be so common…

by U.S. Medicine

August 4, 2016

“It is curious that physical courage should be so common in the world and moral courage so rare.” —Mark Twain (1835-1910)

Editor-In-Chief, Chester "Trip" Buckenmaier III, MD,  COL (ret.), MC, USA

Editor-In-Chief,
Chester “Trip” Buckenmaier III, MD,
COL (ret.), MC, USA

Like many Americans, I find the nightly news of late has been increasingly less palatable and more disturbing. I began formulating this editorial less than 12 hours after the Dallas sniper attacks on police officers, leaving five dead and seven other officers injured. The sniper suspect stated during a standoff with police that “he was upset about Black Lives Matter.” It was further reported that he desired to kill white people, especially white officers.1 I imagine this individual had reached some personal psychological tolerance limit with the ongoing deadly police violence perpetrated on black individuals, and the video of these incidences looped on the cable news networks as a poor excuse for responsible news reporting. 

Before I proceed on this culturally and emotionally charged issue, I want to make something clear. I am not taking a position on the ongoing subject of race and police activity in this country. Each incident of the use of lethal force by police is a tragedy, and each incident must be dealt with individually and within the limits of the law. From my perspective, both sides of this issue have culpability in the violence that has been perpetrated, and both sides have legitimate grievances that deserve atonement. Furthermore, I see the Dallas sniper as an act of domestic terrorism, which is universally unjustified and ethically bankrupt. 

Like Twain, I am curious at how violent displays of physical courage seem to be the predominate method today to resolve cultural and social differences in our society. These thoughtless displays of disagreement through violence are not limited to policing and race relations but are now all too characteristic of political movements, social movements, sports events and even the daily commute (road rage shootings). I am not suggesting that our present society has the corner on the “overuse of violence” market. American history, sadly, is a wasteland of savagery waged by one party against another based on some dubious moral position, concerns over skin color being perhaps one of the silliest positions. What worries me is, more than 100 years after Mark Twain made this rebuke on American society, it seems our culture remains chained to the idea that violence is an appropriate method to further a particular political or cultural point of view. In short, we have not socially evolved from this morally bankrupt practice. 

What has changed is the efficiency (automatic weapons) with which we are able to commit deadly violence on our fellow Americans. Let us pause on the words, “our fellow Americans.” Putting aside your race, your sex or sexual orientation, the vanity in your perceived social class, and the illusion of the importance of your bank account, all that remains of importance is the fact that you are human, the content of your character—Thank you, Dr. King. —and the fact that you are an American. With so many people in this world loathing us and wishing us violence for the simple reason that we are Americans, it defies explanation why we are so busy killing ourselves. 

Being an American has many significant advantages. We have a contract with our government that states we are all created equal. We are granted due process under the law. We have the unalienable right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Mind you, these are not guarantees; they are a framework to make your own way in life while not impinging on the rights of others to do the same. As with any contract, there are provisions and responsibilities (laws) to which each citizen must adhere so we may all enjoy the privileges this society offers. 

This takes a certain amount of moral courage by each citizen to accomplish. It means when you are wronged, you do not immediately respond with a physical act of violence but demonstrate the personal moral fortitude required to work within our system of laws to receive redress. The alternative only offers chaos, misery and death.

Our system of government has created conditions in this country that have facilitated the truly monumental accomplishments of our society. Recently, one of those accomplishments—placing a satellite in orbit around Jupiter, 2.8 billion kilometers away—was overshadowed this week by an individual who thought he was somehow being courageous by responding to perceived race-motivated police violence and completely violated the rights of 12 police officers, five of them permanently. Although race relations and excessive force by police is certainly an important issue, this individual did nothing productive to deal with this difficult social problem. Instead, he only broke the contract with his fellows Americans, committed an act of moral cowardice and weakened our society. 

What does this editorial have to do with federal medicine? Nothing and perhaps everything, I would argue. There is no medical treatment for the moral failings highlighted by this sniper shooting or unjustified violence by police motivated by race. These are social ills for which we all have some responsibility, however. Every thoughtless act, no matter how minor, based on race, skin color, social class or any other nonsensical bias, sets the conditions for events like the Dallas sniper. 

The benefits of our federal medicine institution can only be realized within a stable society. I would suggest that we in federal medicine have benefited tremendously from the society we serve, whether from our careers paths, educational and professional opportunities or the living standards we enjoy. We have a vested interest in working to maintain a stable society and uphold the tenets of the Constitution; many of us have sworn to do so. Society still holds our medical profession in high regard and looks to us as a standard bearer for moral courage. We should be mindful of this position and work to be worthy of emulation. We should strive to demonstrate in our daily lives and interactions with patients the moral courage which seems to be desperately needed by our American society. I cannot help but wonder, as Twain did, whether, if more Americans would strive to perform acts of moral courage in their daily lives, these acts of moral turpitude might become less common? Now that would be a story worthy of the nightly news.

1 Dallas Shooting Leaves 5 Police Officers Dead; Suspect Is Killed. The New York Times. By Patrick McGee, Manny Fernandez, Jonah Engel Bromwich and Richard Pérez-Peña. July 8, 2016.


4 Comments

  • Jane Alderson says:

    Excellent article by Dr. Buckenmaier. We do need more people displaying moral courage by making a conscious effort to spread good will, show kindness and acceptance and by actually helping people. Our society has created an atmosphere of defensiveness, fear, exclusion, persecution, isolation, helplessness and mistrust. This has been creeping more and more into our day to day living and occurs in government, churches, corporations, neighborhoods, etc. You can no longer trust that you’re getting what you paid for, that you can reach a human on the phone, that the rules won’t suddenly change, or that an innocent mistake won’t result in one getting shot. This mistrust and fear is fostered by terrible news coverage that, as Dr. Buckenmaier points out, is lacking in coverage of some of the marvelous things that do happen. Watch the news and everything looks very bleak. Just last night there was a report of a person shooting at another car because of windshield washer fluid spraying their car!
    Spread good will and kindness. Diffuse the anger. Help other humans see it’s possible. “What goes around, comes around”; “you get what you give”.

  • Jane Alderson says:

    Excellent article by Dr. Buckenmaier. We do need more people displaying moral courage by making a conscious effort to spread good will, show kindness and acceptance and by actually helping people. Our society has created an atmosphere of defensiveness, fear, exclusion, persecution, isolation, helplessness and mistrust. This has been creeping more and more into our day to day living and occurs in government, churches, corporations, neighborhoods, etc. You can no longer trust that you’re getting what you paid for, that you can reach a human on the phone, that the rules won’t suddenly change, or that an innocent mistake won’t result in one getting shot. This mistrust and fear is fostered by terrible news coverage that, as Dr. Buckenmaier points out, is lacking in coverage of some of the marvelous things that do happen. Watch the news and everything looks very bleak. Just last night there was a report of a person shooting at another car because of windshield washer fluid spraying their car!
    Spread good will and kindness. Diffuse the anger. Help other humans see it’s possible. “What goes around, comes around”; “you get what you give”.

  • John Lanaghan MD says:

    This should be required teaching in all Junior and Senior High Civics classes.

    “As with any contract, there are provisions and responsibilities (laws) to which each citizen must adhere so we may all enjoy the privileges this society offers.

    This takes a certain amount of moral courage by each citizen to accomplish. It means when you are wronged, you do not immediately respond with a physical act of violence but demonstrate the personal moral fortitude required to work within our system of laws to receive redress. The alternative only offers chaos, misery and death.”

  • John Lanaghan MD says:

    This should be required teaching in all Junior and Senior High Civics classes.

    “As with any contract, there are provisions and responsibilities (laws) to which each citizen must adhere so we may all enjoy the privileges this society offers.

    This takes a certain amount of moral courage by each citizen to accomplish. It means when you are wronged, you do not immediately respond with a physical act of violence but demonstrate the personal moral fortitude required to work within our system of laws to receive redress. The alternative only offers chaos, misery and death.”


Related Articles

In an Age of Incompetence

“I am, as I’ve said, merely competent. But in an age of incompetence, that makes me extraordinary.” ~Billy Joel Like many others who pursue a career in medicine, I invested my early years as a... View Article

“13. The delivery of good medical care is to do as much nothing as possible.” “Laws of the House of God,” —Samuel Shem

I have been a part of U.S. Medicine and this column for several years now. I am occasionally asked where my ideas come from for the editorials I produce. Many ideas, of course, are pulled... View Article


U.S. Medicine Recommends


More From editor in chief

Editor in Chief

In an Age of Incompetence

“I am, as I’ve said, merely competent. But in an age of incompetence, that makes me extraordinary.” ~Billy Joel Like many others who pursue a career in medicine, I invested my early years as a... View Article

Editor in Chief

“13. The delivery of good medical care is to do as much nothing as possible.” “Laws of the House of God,” —Samuel Shem

I have been a part of U.S. Medicine and this column for several years now. I am occasionally asked where my ideas come from for the editorials I produce. Many ideas, of course, are pulled... View Article

Editor in Chief

“When discussing collaboration, people often talk about ‘breaking down silos.’ ... ” —William D. Ramsey, MD

“When discussing collaboration, people often talk about ‘breaking down silos.’ I object to that terminology because ‘breaking down’ is a negative image that implies destruction or tearing down of silos. Academically, silos represent our areas... View Article

Editor in Chief

“God help us, if, the first time something fails—and something will fail—we crush whoever it was … whoever’s responsible,” —Gen. John “Mike” Murray

Gen. Mike Murray made this comment as he became the first commander of the Army Futures Command. The command’s website describes the mission of the organization with the following statement: “Army Futures Command leads a... View Article

Editor in Chief

Healthcare is vital to all of us some of the time, but public health is vital to all of us all of the time. —C. Everett Koop (1916-2013)

It has been with no small amount of dismay that I have watched national maps of the measles outbreak grow progressively redder on the national news as the epidemic continues to spread across the nation.... View Article

Subscribe to U.S. Medicine Print Magazine

U.S. Medicine is mailed free each month to physicians, pharmacists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants and administrators working for Veterans Affairs, Department of Defense and U.S. Public Health Service.

Subscribe Now

Receive Our Email Newsletter

Stay informed about federal medical news, clinical updates and reports on government topics for the federal healthcare professional.

Sign Up