Non-Clinical Topics

VSOs Express Concerns About Making Caregiver Program More Restrictive

by Sandra Basu

May 5, 2018
VA’s Caregiver Support Program has developed several educational programs to assist caregivers in developing new skills sets and understanding the importance of self-care which helps avoid “caregiver burnout” and also helps caregivers achieve a sense of balance to their lives.VA photo

WASHINGTON — Draft legislation that would expand the Family Caregiver Program but make eligibility for the program more restrictive raised concerns for several veterans’ groups.

The draft legislation was discussed at a hearing held by the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs Subcommittee on Health last month. The current Family Caregiver Program criteria include that the post-9/11 veteran must need help with one activity of daily living to qualify.

While the draft legislation would expand the benefit to pre-9/11 veterans and their caregivers, it also would limit eligibility to veterans who need help with three or more activities of daily living. “The American Legion could never support a bill that would reduce benefits for veterans,” responded Louis Celli, director of the American Legion National Veterans Affairs and Rehabilitation Division. Veterans of Foreign Wars also “would oppose setting up arbitrary eligibility requirements, such as increasing the criteria to three activities of daily living in efforts to lower costs,” said Kayda Keleher, national legislative service associate director.

In introducing the bill, House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs Chairman Rep. Phil Roe (R-TN) explained that he was “committed” to a separate compromise agreement under discussion with Sen. Johnny Isakson (R-GA) and Sen. Jon Tester (D-MT) of the Senate Committee on Veterans’ Affairs to expand the program to pre-9/11 veterans without making any changes to the eligibility criteria. Roe said he hoped to “see movement on it.”

He added, however, that “should negotiations prove unfruitful, we must have an honest conversation about finding the right balance between clinical appropriateness and the cost within this program and make needed changes to ensure it is working as intended for increasing its participants in such a dramatic fashion.”

Caregiver Expansion

Advocates of expanding the benefit to caregivers of veterans of all eras had wanted the change included in an omnibus spending bill passed in March, but the broader benefit did not make it into the final version of the bill that ultimately passed.

The expansion of the caregiver program has been a source of congressional debate in recent years, as advocacy groups have pushed for it. Veterans’ groups supported the Senate version of a Choice reform bill last year that includes a provision that would expand comprehensive care to veterans of all eras without changing the criteria. Yet, a House version of the bill did not include a provision expanding caregiver benefits.

At a hearing on the issue in February, then-VA Secretary David Shulkin, MD, told lawmakers that VA favored changing the clinical criteria of the program so that only the caregivers of veterans who need help with at least three activities of daily living are eligible, as well as those with cognitive dysfunction. As part of that, Shulkin emphasized he was not in support of revoking the benefit for veterans who already use the program.

Shulkin said that if Congress expanded the benefit to pre-9/11 veterans without changing current eligibility requirements, in 10 years, VA would have about 188,000 caregivers, up from the 26,000 caregivers that currently are in the program.

If VA used a criteria “that would be a little bit more discriminatory” and limit eligibility to those who are the most severely ill or injured veterans, then the number would be 40,000 additional caregivers in the pre-9/11 group, he explained.

Roe said his draft legislation has been “in development since the full committee hearing on the program in early February and has been the subject of multiple roundtable discussions with VA and veterans service organizations since that time.”

Meanwhile, some lawmakers also expressed reservations with provisions in the bill. Rep. Ann Kuster (D-NH) wondered about the clinical basis of the draft bill criteria and said she “can’t imagine medically that has any basis in reality.”

Rep. Mark Takano (D-CA) said that he prefers the Senate version of the bill and that he would not “support anything that would diminish the benefits for any veteran.”

Disabled American Veterans Deputy National Legislative Director Adrian Atizado said that he would prefer making the compromise agreement under discussion by lawmakers “a reality,” before having the conversation on the more restrictive draft bill.

“We have a historic opportunity before us,” Atizado noted.

Paralyzed Veterans of America, meanwhile, would also prefer the compromise agreement under discussion, said Associate Legislative Director Sarah Dean, who added that, as the draft proposal “would make eligible veterans with catastrophic injuries of all eras, PVA would support it as a first step to full expansion.”


Comments are closed here.


Related Articles

VA: Blue Water Veterans Must Wait Until 2020 for Claims to Be Processed

Vietnam Vets on Ships Won Fight for Presumptive Agent Orange Status WASHINGTON—Blue Water Navy veterans who want to file disability claims related to Agent Orange exposure will have to wait until next year to have... View Article

Debate Continues on Esketamine Efficacy and Safety for Depression Treatment

VA Panel Puts Limits on Use of Drug PHILADELPHIA—Is esketamine a revolutionary treatment for depression or just another moderately effective adjunctive medication with some potentially serious risks? The VA’s Medical Advisory Panel leaned toward the... View Article


U.S. Medicine Recommends


More From legislation

Legislation

VA: Blue Water Veterans Must Wait Until 2020 for Claims to Be Processed

Vietnam Vets on Ships Won Fight for Presumptive Agent Orange Status WASHINGTON—Blue Water Navy veterans who want to file disability claims related to Agent Orange exposure will have to wait until next year to have... View Article

Legislation

VA Reverses Stance, Won’t Challenge ‘Blue Water’ Veteran Court Ruling

WASHINGTON—In an about-face, the VA will recommend that the federal government not challenge a recent court decision ruling that the department cannot deny benefits to Vietnam-era Blue Water Navy veterans claiming Agent Orange exposure. The... View Article

Legislation

Executive Order Creates Task Force to Combat Veteran Suicide

WASHINGTON—President Donald Trump has signed an executive order aimed at lowering the rate of veteran suicides. The order—the President’s Roadmap To Empower Veterans and End a National Tragedy of Suicide—creates a Cabinet-level task force led... View Article

Legislation

Legislators Express Outrage Over Military Sexual Trauma Issues Subhead: Senator Describes Her Experience as Air Force Rape Victim

WASHINGTON—A recent survey of the military service academies found that sexual assault has spiked over the last two years, up 50% since 2016. This news sparked fresh outrage from legislators, resulting in a hearing focusing... View Article

Legislation

Senate Votes Overwhelmingly to Make Robert L. Wilkie the New VA Secretary

Robert L. Wilkie took office as the 10th VA Secretary after the U.S. Senate voted 86-9 to confirm him.

Subscribe to U.S. Medicine Print Magazine

U.S. Medicine is mailed free each month to physicians, pharmacists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants and administrators working for Veterans Affairs, Department of Defense and U.S. Public Health Service.

Subscribe Now

Receive Our Email Newsletter

Stay informed about federal medical news, clinical updates and reports on government topics for the federal healthcare professional.

Sign Up